Photos and listing copy only tell you what a seller wants to show. Direct questions, asked before you pay, tell you how transparent that seller actually is, and a seller's willingness (or unwillingness) to answer specifically is often more informative than the answers themselves.
Why Asking Directly Works
A reputable seller can usually answer questions about origin, grade, and sourcing quickly and specifically, because they already know these details about their own stock. A seller who is vague, defensive, or gives a different answer each time you ask is showing you something useful: either they don't know what they're selling, or they'd rather you didn't ask too closely. Either way, that's worth knowing before you pay.
Questions About Origin and Sourcing
Ask whether the product is wild-harvested or cultivated, and which specific country or region it comes from, rather than accepting a general "Southeast Asian agarwood" answer. For wild-harvested material crossing borders, ask whether it's CITES-compliant and whether documentation is available, covered in more detail in our guide to agarwood and conservation. A seller who can name a specific region and harvest method confidently is generally more trustworthy than one who can't.
Questions About Grade and Quality
Ask what grading system the seller uses and what it means by their own standard, since terms like "Super" or "Grade A" aren't standardized across sellers, covered in our guide to how agarwood is graded. For chips specifically, ask whether the wood sinks, semi-sinks, or floats. For oil, ask whether it's been tested or verified in any way, and whether the seller can describe the distillation method used.
Want the full picture on telling genuine agarwood from fake before you ask?
Fake Oud: What to Look ForFormat-Specific Questions
For beads, ask about the bead count, species, and whether any dyeing or treatment was used, covered in our guide to buying agarwood beads. For oil, ask about purity, whether anything has been added, and how the oil was stored and aged, covered in our guide to buying oud oil. Tailoring your questions to the specific format you're buying gets you more useful answers than asking generic questions about "quality."
Questions About Documentation and Returns
Ask whether the seller can provide any documentation, certificates of origin, CITES permits for wild material, or lab reports for oil, and ask directly about their return or satisfaction policy before you buy, since many fragrance sellers don't accept returns once a bottle is opened, covered in our guide to buying oud oil. Getting this in writing before you pay avoids disputes later.
Reading the Answers
Specific, consistent, confidently-given answers are a good sign. Vague answers, answers that contradict the listing, or reluctance to answer at all are reasons to slow down, covered further in our guide to red flags when buying agarwood. If you'd rather start with sellers who've already been vetted on points like these, our supplier directory is a useful place to begin.